What is the real value of music education? Is it to produce robot performers or to produce people who are artists in some less tangible way? Thinking of Orff and Kodaly has made me wonder: why music education, especially in places where there aren't many resources or outlets for formal music making? Being a true artist is more than robot production. A really good basic music education sparks off something deeper in people, so whatever they go on to do in life, it sticks with them in some small way. That's why I think music education is an essential part of the curriculum.
I don't know what system they had in the school I attended. From kindergarten, we started the day with activity. Moving, clapping, banging triangles and tambourines. Some of the kids were already getting piano lessons at home, but in school, the emphasis was having fun, not producing music. Mental and emotional stimulation - calisthenics for the soul.
Because this was a good school, there were thousands of applicants for each place. Huge pressure, but pressure can inspire as well as destroy. Everyone knows about the Oxbridge syndrome where students who were top in secondary school suddenly come adrift in a milieu where everyone is mega bright. Although my school was for the academically gifted, we were instilled from the start with the ethos of "giving". The idea was that the world gave us so much, we would give in return. Lots more fancy terminology possible, but that's what it meant. You are part of society, not out for yourself. So music was part of that process. "Listening to others" as the Orff Schulwerk teacher said.
It used to drive other schools crazy that we won nearly every single prize for singing, reciting and orchestra in every single music festival for more than 60 years. But for us it wasn't competitive, it was fun and emotionally satisfying. "To be the best you can be, whatever you do."
In Chinese society, pressure to strive comes from a historical background. If your children benefit, then suffering can be borne. Even by Chinese standards, Lang Lang was cruelly treated by his father. But he fought back. He's a lot more independent than he gets credit for, which is part of his appeal. So what if he's not divine musically? He's admired for who he is. I don't have much time for Tiger Mothers who are getting so much attention in the western press, because they operate outside the communal context. It's their spineless husbands who can't stick up for their kids in a different environment.
Pressure does not "have" to be negative and joyless. Enjoy this clip of 10, 11 and 12 year olds doing their best and having tremendous fun. The teacher herself grew up in that system. Once she too was little, banging a triangle and having fun.
Everyone knows Carmina Burana, even if they think it's the sound track to TV ads. Ironic then, that Carl Orff should be the subject of O Fortuna, the 2008 documentary by Tony Palmer. Because Carmina Burana is so familiar, responses to Carl Orff himself are coloured by "TV thinking", superficial, ill informed and kneejerk, like the cliché that Carmina Burana is a Nazi tract. But Orff deserves deeper analysis. He was a conundrum, a complex person who concealed his inner life even from himself. He's a conundrum. Yet his legacy benefits millions who don't care or know much about European music or history.
Palmer's documentary doesn't attempt psychological depth but presents material that might otherwise lurk in archives. Orff's daughter Godela appears, as do Orff's last two wives. At least one of them is dead. I don't know when the interviews were made, or by whom, but they're valuable sources. The footage of the last wife, Liselotte, is vivid and moving, probably seen for the first time.
Michael Kater appears too, to add perspectiuve. "Orff wasn't a Nazi, he hated what they stood for", he says, but Orff also didn't make life difficult for himself. He figured that when Pfiztner and Richard Strauss died he'd be the most important composer in the Reich. Big consideration. Always broke, he accepted money from the State, but that didn't automatically compromise him. Ralph Vaughan Wiliams and Sibelius did so too. More worrying was that he didn't help Kurt Huber, whose White Rose cell resisted Hitler, yet later claimed he'd actively helped. It's relevant that Karl Amadeus Hartmann, who knew everyone involved, treated Orff with sympathy. Unless you've lived in a closed totalitarian state, moral ambiguities are hard to judge. Perhaps Orff felt survivor guilt and needed to convince himself. A warped way of making amends, but, as Kater says, "psychologically significant".
Orff's other legacy was Schulwerk, the concept idea that music was a fundamental source of expression. One of the most remarkable moments in the film comes when a Schulwerk teacher tells of a first year child in a war zone who came to school deeply withdrawn. Her family had been massacred in the night and the child didn't know what to do, so she went to school. Later, there's a clip of children with learning disabilities using the system as therapy. What the film doesn't do is connect the Schulwerk ethos to the wider issues of Orff's personality. By its very nature the concept eschews wealth, power and status. It's based on the simplest forms of expression, as simple as using the body. "Everyone has a voice within themselves" says another teacher. "We don't listen to each other, we don't listen to ourselves.... but you cannot make music without listening. Orff teaches us to listen for more than notes, to listen to others and to the world around us in which we all live".
The film doesn't make the connection between what Orff's system teaches and who Orff was as a man, but I think they are inextricable. Godela Orff spoke about her father's childhood fascination with puppets and fantasy. Theatre is a form of expression through which you can explore feelings and ideas without necessarily putting yourself in jeopardy. Orff wasn't personally warm and giving, perhaps because he was quite vulnerable within. Hence the contradictions in his life. Yet he intuited how others could find themselves. He couldn't deal with reality too well, but he recognized that the process of becoming a whole person was through expression.
Curiously the film hardly deals with Orff''s music at all. It's loosely based around a semi staged performance of Carmina Burana, but the music isn't integrated into the narrative. Yet, since it's the one piece everyone knows, it does need confronting. Listen to its angular rhythmic shapes and the violent surges of sound. These fool many into thinking it's a Nuremburg rally in music. But then listen carefully. The texts depict a medieval world where life was short and barbaric, where pleasure had to be grasped in an almost animalistic way before inevitable death. Strictly speaking not all that different from living in the 20th century. Godela claims that the piece was at first greeted with stunned silence until she cried out, "Listen you bastards!". Maybe she too muddled memory with wish, for young girls don't dare confront Party brass like that. Quite likely that the audience didn't know what to think as these brutal jagged rhythms do have an affinity with "primitive" non-white music. Orff had lived through the Weimar after all. Normally music like this might have been considered degenerate, but the audience was fooled by the fake Germanism. Remember Hartmann and Simplcius Simplicissimus.
What I really didn't like about the film was that it started with an ad and ended with an ad. Brand names prominently emphasized. We know the music is used in ads, but this is so blatant that it turns the film into a commercial. Orff was morally compromised because he took the easy way with the Reich. Is the film morally compromised since it has no qualms about commercial exploitation? Pretty tacky. I'm sorry but this ruined the integrity of the film for me. Orff, for all his faults, wasn't crass.
Franz Schreker was "a master of interior states" writes Christopher Hailey, Schreker's biographer. "The protagonists of his operas are driven by emotional psychology rather than by external events, ideas or philosophical concepts". Not Wagner or Mahler then. Nor quite the world of Ewartung or Wozzeck. Schreker's songs are interesting, approached on their own terms, like snapshots of experience, contained within the limits of piano song.
Only 33 of Schreker's 49 songs were published in his lifetime, the remainder only in 2005. This CD Songs of Franz Schreker (Bridge 9259) is the most extensive recording,. Wolfgang Holzmair, Hermine Haselböck and Russel Ryan are excellent. One could hardly hope for better performances. Holzmair specializes in less well known Austrian repertoire, so his interpretation evolves from long familiarity with the period. His voice is clear, clean and assertive, yet with a soft Austrian burr that adds a warm glow. Haselböck has an equally elegant style, which suits these songs well. One, Im Garten unter der Linde dates from 1896, when Schreker was only 17.
Much more attractive is Das hungernde Kind, from 1898. It's the same text from Des Knaben Wunderhorn that Mahler used in Das iridische Lebenfive years previously. Schreker's setting is briskly foursquare. No angst here, no psychological insight whatsoever. The tempo quickens slightly as the child gets more frantic, while the mother's music smiles, enigmatically. One shouldn't sympathise with child abuse, but the song's so charming, Yet what can it mean?
From this period also come two Mutterlieder songs to poems by Mai Holm, which Schreker revised extensively and published as his op 5. They're here in context with other, unconnected songs about the death of children Like post mortem photographs, songs about the death of children were popular in the 19th century when child mortality was high. Although Schreker's sister had died some years before, it's probably not a good idea to read anything too personal into these songs of lyrical, stylized grief. If anything, the imagery fits best with the songs of flowers, a symbol of beauty that fades too fast. Rosengruss is attrractively ornamented, but for me the most touching is Rosentod to a poem by Dora Leen (Dora Pollack) who was for a while engaged to Schreker and who died in a concentration camp in the 1940's. There are three other songs to her poems, Spuk,Traum and Sommerrfaden, all set with a delicate touch so the naive simplicity of the poems isn't compromised.
More sophisticated, and more musically satisfying are the later songs, such as four of the five settings of poems by Edith Ronsperger (1880-1921), written in 1909, included to give a broader perspective. One of the best known is Der Dunkleheit sinkt schwer wei Blie (Darkness falls as heavy as lead). Hailey draws the parallels with Schoenberg, in particularly Ewartung, though it's a much less complex piece and lasts only 3 minutes. But Schreker blends oppressive dark chords with menacing intervals. It's highly dramatic, even though it doesn't develop into something more. This is Schreker, opera composer, showing what he can do with song.
It's also the spirit of Expressionism. The Cabinet of Dr Caligari (click link for full download)! The current fashion for downgrading modernism would have it that Schreker was retrogressive and backward-looking. Just as the Nazis suppressed composers like Schreker, "fans" these days suppress what makes them modern and worthwhile. Schreker knew Schoenberg, for example, and was well aware of society changing around him. He had no illusions about conservatism or tradition for its own sake. Think Irrelohe with its premonitions of the collapse of the old order. So it's good that this worthy recording includes the song Das feurige Männlein from 1915. A troll astride a demonic stallion. It's First World War Feuerreiter, unleashing Armageddon in his trail. Weh! schreien die Menschen, die Bäum' und die Stein' - und das feuerige Männlein lauscht graig hinein.
Please see my other posts on Schreker, more here than other sites.
Jacques Imbrailo and John Mark Ainsley together again in Britten Billy Budd, this time in Amsterdam. Obviously, can't tell production from a few shots, but it looks interesting. More emphasis on the "inner" story as told through the music, than the "outer" story? Britten was interested in Captain Vere's moral dilemma, and the image of goodness and freedom Billy represents. Much more to this opera than shipboard romance.
Wang Tian-lin's The Wild Wild Rose (野玫瑰之戀) (1960) is a very important film because it adapts Bizet's Carmen to make extremely pointed commentary on Chinese values at a time of great upheaval in Chinese society. It's set in Hong Kong, a city where everyone was a refugee, even the local born. Millions of people had been dislocated in China after decades of war and chaos. Like many films at that time, The Wild, Wild Rose begins with shots of neon lights and glittering nightlife, symbolizing prosperity. But this hedonism unfolds against a background of extreme suffering and deprivation. Understanding this context is fundamental to a deeper reading of the film.
The Wild, Wild Rose stars Grace Chang (Ge Lan 葛蘭) as Deng Sijia, a charismatic nightclub singer. Significantly, she's by no means a typical chanteuse. She has complete artistic control over what she does and uses her act to make statements. She's individualistic and feisty, "wild", a rose with thorns. But her fans adorte her. "I like noisy women", says one man, "they aren't boring". Not quite the typical model of a Nice Chinese Maiden.
In one scene, the commotion Sijia's act raises draws the customers away from the nightclub next door. The other nightclub features the kind of westernized crooner complete with "jazz band", that was the norm in cities like Shanghai and Hong Kong as early as the 1920's. These clubs were a means through which those who had money could display their wealth and sophisticated taste. The point this film is making, though, is that the musical fare was ersatz. Sijia's nightclub stands for artistic integrity.
Liang Hanhua (Yang Chang) takes a job as nightclub pianist. He trained as a classical musician, and despises "nightclub" people". He represents the old scholar class who disdained the world of merchants the nightclub patrons come from. Old money and education, however, mean nothing now that war and dislocation have wrecked traditional values. Throughout the film, there are allusions to class, status and social mores, which Sijia challenges.
Everyone's living on the edge. Sudden reversals of fate, poverty and wealth, just as in real life Hong Kong and in China for the last 100 years. The nightclub is a microcosm of society, where callousness destroys people. The old pianist Old Wang (Lei da) is kicked out of work because he's late. He's late because his wife is dying and he can't afford medicine. Maybe he, too, was a classical pianist, but now he lives in a squalid cubicle with three screaming kids. In those days apartments didn't have rooms, people rented floor space cordoned off by boards. Communal living, but in an urban setting. Liang feels guilt about displacing Old Wang but there's nothing he can do.
Deng Sijia as the Carmen archetype shakes up all assumptions. Obviously, sexuality comes into the mix, because Ge Lan is gorgeous. She hands Liang a score. "You can't sing this" he says, because he knows La donna è mobile should be sung by The Duke in Rigoletto. But Deng understands its meaning. She overturns the Duke's refusal to accept responsibility for his actions. Women are fickle, she implies, because they can't depend on men. She's dressed as Escamillo in cape and toreador hat. Later she appears in a man's flamenco costume, wearing tight pants with buttons up to her waist. Gender stereotypes are shattered.
When Deng Sijia sings the Habanera, it's a glorious shout of liberation. "Love is an illusion" she sings, "I have fun with men rich or poor, whatever their class". Listen to how she exhales like she's in coitus. Ther camera pans on her naked legs. It couldn't be more explict. There's also another song Jajambo! which might not mean much today but is a reference to 50's ideas of cha cha, jazz and the exotic "wild" that were popular in nightclubs in those days.
Sijia decides to teach Hanhua a lesson about being snobbish. She seduces him while singing The Merry Widow. He can't figure out how a lowlife knows so much about classical repertoire. We know nothing about her background except that she's been on the streets since she was 14. Maybe she, too, came from the upper classes and dreamed of better things, but she's suffered like everyone else in China at the time. She's beautiful, but to get where she is, she's been through hell.
Gender reversal in this film isn't about sexual preference but about politics. The nightclub is society in microcosm. Nightclub hostesses are bought like commodities but Deng doesn't play the game. "I sing", she tells her friend who has a sugar daddy, "I don't sleep with customers". Just as she doesn't sell out as an artist, she doesn't sell herself.
Liang Hanhua cannot cope even when they fall in love. He's so fixated on the old order that even when he's alcoholic and unemployed, he won't let Sijia do her thing or make a living. His fiancée isn't much better. She, Wu Suxin (Yun Shen) represents traditional Chinese female models of deference, though she in fact pulls the apron strings. She needs, for example, to escort Hanhua to and from work like a child, so he won't get contaminated. She manipulates him by using his mother's authority. But as Sijia says, there's no difference between traditional womern and prostitutes. "You want him for permanent rice ration", Sijia tells Suxin.
Yet even Sijia, like Carmen, cannot escape. Sijia goes back to work, in her audition for a new nightclub, she sings Un bel di, dressed as Madama Butterfly, the nice girl forced into prostitution who sacrifices herself for love. In 1960 the image was still slightly shocking as memories of the Japanese occupation were still fresh. It's a parody of submissiveness. The disfigured triad boss who used to own Sijia comes out of jail and wants to claim her. Hanhua tries to kill him, in an interesting reversal of the Don José/Escamillo theme. When Hanhua gets out of prison in his turn, Sijia is waiting, faithfully. But Hanhua still can't handle the situation. Instead of finding out what's really going on, he stabs Sijia in a fit of rage. Even Suxin thinks he's a fool.
Ultimately, it's Sijia who makes the more altruistic sacrifice, compared to Suxin, making Sijia a true Chinese heroine after all. She dies, but she shows the way for others. In the end it's meek Old Wang, who represents mindless, uncomplaining sorrow, who explodes. Sijia raised money to save his wife, and Hanhua has killed her because he doesn't understand the real value of money, which is to benefit others. "How could you do that!" Old Wang howls, in indignation. Sijia's dead but we aren't supposed to accept the old order any more.
Beneath this Carmennarrative lies political dynamite. Like Bizet's Carmen, the Wild, Wild Rose deals with alternatives to conventional social norms. But Sijia isn't a gypsy outsider but an otherwise normal Chinese girl, with more education and sophistication than she's given credit for. Sijia could be Everywoman. In the context of Chinese society, she's truly subversive. So radical, indeed, that The Wild Wild Rose could teach western culture a thing or two.
This amazing movie needs to be understood, too, in the context of Chinese film and social history.Far too often Chinese culture is judged through west centric parameters, which totally distorts the perspective. It's a throwback to racist, imperialist colonial values. Instead, appreciate Chinese film from a Chinese background. The first Chinese movies were being made as early as 1909, not all that long after Mélies in France, and preceding The Keystone Cops and Chaplin in the US. Right from the start, film was seen as a medium through which modern ideas could be promoted. The first Cantonese film makers were politically radical. Lai Man Wai (Li Minhui 黎民偉, 1893-1955) was a supporter of Sun Yat sen. Watch the clip for more detail. Rumour has it that Lai used film equipment to smuggle guns to the rebels during the Xinhai uprising in 1911. One of the principles of the May Fourth Movement was to create change through education. Literature, film, and the arts were the weapons of this "real" Revolution, not guns or warlords. Thus, many early Chinese films address modern issues against feudal practice. All Chinese modernizers emphasized social conscience, one of the basic principles of Sun Yat Sen's revolution, but also a tradition that goies back to Confucios and Buddha and the scholar ideal of social service. There is no "right wing" iu the modErn western sense.Ge Lan herself came from a prominent Gou Min Dang family, and worked in Taiwan.
Many of the earliest filmmakers were from Guangdong Province, with close links to Hong Kong and overseas Chinese communities. most of which were southern in origin. Indeed, the first studios, even in Shanghai, were founded by southerners. The Cantonese film community was so big that the first really big Chinese movie star, Ruan Lingyu (Yuen Ling yuk 阮玲玉 1910-35) couldn't speak Mandarin, the northern and national language. Luckily, her films were silents. Again, Ge Lan is a radical. Unlike so many other Chinese actressses who coimmitted suidide and had sad lives, Grace Chang ius still alive in California. Look how healthy she is, and how athletic (see Mambo Girl). She wasn't the first feisty Chinese heroine (think Li Lili) but she's a role model for modern women. Wang Tian lin, who directed, and his producers, obviously came from a later generation, but one which was even more radicalized. The Chinese film industry was left liberal. Indeed, there was no real "Right" in China since all, even the Blueshirts, respected Sun Yatsen's Three Principles of social justice in theory if not in practice. Many film people declared for communism after 1949, and those who didn't emigrated if they could. While once there was a Guangdong community in Shanghai, there was now a huge Shanghai community in Hong Kong. The Wild Wild Rose is thus a product of an exile community, made in a city where everyone had been a refugee, as Hong Kong itself had been depopulated under Japanese occupation. Everyone involved in this film, at every level, including Ge Lan herself, was a refugee who knew about trauma first hand. There are no gypsies in this version of Carmen, and Deng Sijia is an insider, but the whole film is a paradigm of dislocation and social chaos. So this film is, in a way, the voice of a minority that speaks for us all.
HERE is a link to buy the DVD. I've used Yesasia before, they're OK. Always check DVD Region first. LOTS of other Carmen pieces on this site, (Lubitsch, Chaplin etc) incl full movie downloads, the early recordings of the Habanera (1891!) etc. Also even reviews of the Bizet opera ! Click on label at right that says "Carmen".
After hearing his stunning Leporello at Glyndebourne and his Figaro at Salzburg, there was no way I was going to miss Luca Pisaroni's concert with Wolfram Rieger at the Wigmore Hall yesterday. But I was delighted by how wonderful he sounded close up in recital.
Extremely erudite choice of programme too. When Pisaroni started singing, it fell into place. He's primarily an opera singer and a specialist in Italian repertoire, Mozart and baroque.. He was even grew up in Busseto, Verdi's birthplace, so he he could coast to the top "to the manner born".
So the fact that he chose an unusually intelligent programme says a lot about his versatility and musical instinct. He's also smart enough to have figured out the Wigmore Hall ethos. Although the auditorium wasn't full, those who were there were the real cognoscenti, serious listeners who really appreciate good singing (and good programmes). Some of them are getting on in years and don't get out as much as they used to, so the fact that they were there is a huge compliment to Pisaroni.
And Pisaroni delivered! Schubert wrote several operas in Italian, but instead of singing "bleeding chunks", Pisaroni picked Drei Gesänge, D902, (Metastasio, 1827) which look like excerpts but were written as stand-alones. This integrity brings them closer to Schubert's song repertoire. They're Italianate but Schubert's Austrian aesthetic is clearly distinct. Pisaroni placed the last song in the group first, Il modo di prender moglie, (How to choose a wife - for money!) which was a good idea. It's a strophic comic ballad which doesn't make great demands and lulls you into forgetting who the composer might be. Then, the first song L'incanto degli occhi (the magic of eyes) where the trure Schubertian voice is unmistakable. What a witty juxtaposition! Pisaroni not only has an amazingly good voice, but musical intelligence, too. Then you appreciate the humour in , (the deluded traitor) which isn't morbid, despite the title. When Pisaroni sang Ove son io? (Where am I?), and repeated it cryptically, I had a vivid mental image of Schubert, frustrated by having too little success in a genre he needed to master if he'd compete with changing fashions.
Hence, Rossini. Again, Pisaroni chose songs rather than bits from popular operas, to connect better with Schubert. Pisaroni is a bass baritone, so the darker timbres were extremely beautiful, but the voice is agile and flexible, so the transits upwards come with ease. Truly a gorgeous voice, full of nuance and colour.
Franz Liszt wrote transcriptions of Schubert's songs which are still popular today, though they sound much more Lisztian than Schubertian. They're florid, as if Liszt can't quite get the Lieder aesthetic and submerges it in too many notes. That's OK, they're different composers. Liszt also knew Schumann, the "new music" of the 1840's. There are well over 70 Liszt songs for voice and piano, but Pisaroni again chose thoughtfully. Two settings of Heine, one of which, Im Rhein im schönen Strome is indelibly associated with Dichterliebe and Schumann. Liszt's S272 (1855) is a more studied piece, reflecting a different approach to song, which is quite distinct, though the text in the last verse demands strong phrasing.
Pisaroni and Rieger followed with three songs Schumann didn't set, to emphasize Liszt's unique style. There are vaguely Schumannesque passages in the piano parts, though Liszt doesn't write extended preludes and postludes. Der Vätergruft (1844, Uhland) displays Liszt's gifts as dramatist. The ghost of a knight joins his ancestors in their tomb. Die Geisterlaute verhallten, da mocht es gar stille sein. (ghostly sounds fade and silence reigns again). This could almost be a song without words, it's so effective.
This extremely well planned recital ended with Liszt's Tre sonetti di Petrarca S270 in the version for baritone and piano. Liszt as pianist triumphs. This isn't Germanic Lieder by any means but completely unique. Reiger played with great delicacy, matched by Pisaroni's sensitive modulation. His Benedetto sia'l giorno is truly a love song. He lingers gently on the words E i sospiri e le lagrime so they feel like a gentle caress. An exquiste recital wonderfully realized. Next time Pisaroni appears, there should be queues around the block. He's singing Argante in Handel's Rinaldo at Glyndebourne this summer with Sandrine Piau, who did fascinating programme of Schubert transcriptions last week. (See review here) So we've heard both Pisaroni and Piau in two unusual recitals in the same week at the Wigmore Hall. Brilliant!
photo : Marco Borggreve
Roderick Williams and Helmut Deutsch gave an interesting programme last week at the Wigmore Hall, London. I didn't go (I was at Eschenbach) but my friends did. Here's a review in Opera Today. Roddy as they call him, sings English par excellence and took a while to perfect singing in German but now he's mature and has the idiom right. Lots more to singing Mahler than just sounds. Read about his early Mahler concert a few years ago and above all his English song. No-one but no-one does English better than he. Butterworth, Finzi, Elgar, etc etc follow labels
It's Hungary, 1956, and the people have been rising up against the Russians. Tanks are rolling in and the revolt is about to be crushed. György Cziffra is scheduled to play Bartók's Piano Concerto no 2. What can he do? This is how he makes his stand. (concerto in 2 parts)
Bizet's Carmen bombed when it was first heard. Too difficult, too decadent! They couldn't give tickets away. Now it's the world's favourite opera, known even to people who don't know what opera is. So bear that in mind when assessing Carmen in 3D from the Royal Opera House. I'd never seen a 3D movie in my life, so was worried by some negative pre publicity from people who don't know the production or film. Anything new upsets people. But Carmen in 3D isn't the end of civilization. It's just new technology applied to something familiar.
Carmen was the first opera to be filmed, in 1D and silent, which defeats the purpose of opera, but still appealed as a story. Look at two early Carmen films - Charlie Chaplin's 1915 Burlesque on Carmen and Ernst Lubitsch's 1921 Gypsy Blood. They are so hammy it's embarrassing. But film was such a novelty then that people didn't have preconceptions of what filmed opera should and shouldn't be. 3D or RealD, to use its proper name, is so new that it hasn't really evolved. I don't think it's as big an advance as 2D (HD) is on 1D but it's never a good idea to write anything off too soon.
This is after all the first opera on 3D, the start of a learning curve. Indeed, it's not even aimed at an opera audience so much as at the 3D market. There aren't that many 3D films around, so there's plenty of commercial pressure to produce more and expand the range. Now that everyone can watch DVDs at home, cinemas need something unique to beat the competition. The idea is to give people an experience they can't do at home. What's so bad about making the movies a social occasion again? And why shouldn't 3D audiences have opera instead of theur usual fare?
It's extremely significant that the first 3D opera is Carmen, and not something esoteric. Francesca Zambello's production is safe and popular, which is why it's been revived so many times. Everyone's seen it before, and there's even a DVD with Antonacci and Kaufmann. So serious opera goers have nothing to lose. Why not share the fun with people who might not otherwise go? For many, just seeing inside the Royal Opera House might be a revelation. Normal people in the audience! The singers are shown before and after as perople, being made up and taking their bows. This film counteracts the elitist image of opera and might bring in new audiences. For all we know, teenagers might watch this. They've been known to discover opera in the past.
The film is very different to the opera experienced live. Somehow the colour process has been drained out, so the film is very dark and oppressive, like early Technicolor in the 1940's where all the tones are faded. Wearing X ray specs doesn't help. I took mine off and there was some improvement. But without the shining golds and jewel tones on the Toréador and Torrero costumes a lot of the splendour is gone. Live, Escamillo's entry on that huge black stallion takes your breath away, it's so wonderful. Here it looks like a different horse altogether. Even the cortege of candles in the procession doesn't shine. Some details work well, like the leather corset Carmen wears, but much of the impact of Zambello's production is lost. I don't know if the cause is technical or a result of the filming.
This Carmen wasn't made for 3D or even for film, which is an advantage because the director, Julian Napier, doesn't need to strive for special effects. So don't have nightmares about this being anything like the 3D horror movies of the 1950's. At the beginning, Bryan Hymel reaches out at the camera, and his hands are distorted like crazy. Then you see him grin. It's a joke! The movie avoids obvious stunts as much as possible, though there are odd moments, such as when guyropes cross the camera's field of vision or actors run across the outer edges.
Zambello's staging is notoriously horizontal, so I was hoping there might be more shots from different angles, such as from the ramparts, as the crowd scenes can't be seen too clearly. One plus of 3D is that it adds depth to this production. For example, when the soldiers assemble in the market place, the camera follows the arch they make. Crowd scenes are much more clearly defined. Part of the meaning of the opera pivots on the iidea of private individual as opposed to public persona. 3D actually makes this clearer, since key figures really do stand out from the background. Carmen in particular benefits, because she seems even more alone in 3D than she does live. I suspect with time, film makers will realize that with 3D less is more, The details that really improve are small things like the way Christine Rice crosses the fingers in her hands, like a protective hollow, not "big" movements like jumping and runnning.
Which bodes well, as less is always more on film. Closeups help. Carmen does not need the kind of semaphore acting Chaplin and Lubitsch were forced to use in their day. Because she comes from a very upper class background and has a Cambridge degree, Carmen-as-slut doesn't come naturally to Christine Rice. Instead, she portrays Carmen as a tense personality living on the edge, which is perfectly true. Like most people who use sex to manipulate others, Carmen probably doesn't really enjoy it. So when Rice looks at Escamillo and suddenly relaxes, you knw what it means.
Performances all round are good, but the orchestra really comes into its own in this film. The Royal Opera House orchestra is always reliable, but conductor Constantinos Carydis gets specially vivid playingvfrom them so the music pulsates with energy and colour. Like many in this cast he may not be a household name outside Europe but so what? Europeans kmnow a little bit about music. Besides, he's good and that's the most important thing. 3D is good for filming orchestras. It gives visual depth, so the difference between rows of musicians feels more realistic. And when you can see depth, your mind picks it up aurally, too.
A few weeks ago I went to an excellent conference at UCL on "Carmen and Her others" whichgh was about the Carmen archetype as it adapts from novel to opera into other genres and locales. Last count there were over 100 variations on the theme, including from several different parts of Africa, and China, and versions in rock and pop. Beyoncé stars in a hip hop version ! (Please see descriptions of numerous versions on nthis site by using the Carmen label on right) . So the world can take a 3D Carmen, no problem.
The trouble with all the "reviews" in the press is that they are written as reviews of the performance by people who clearly haven't seen much opera. It's irrelevant whether this is a good or bad production, or even a good or bad opera. It's not news, ikt's been around forever. What is news, and what they're supposed to be reviewing is how the 3D realization works or doesn't. So it's all ther more refreshing read this article here where someone has taken the trouble to think. Like the man says, "I'll take Herzog's opinion".
It's taken me a week to write about the Barbican BBC Brian Fernyhough Total Immersion. Firstly, this is not music for instant reactions. Secondly I was upset at the poor presentation. Just as you can't learn a language in small doses, you can't learn Ferneyhough's language superficially. That's why, five years ago, I suggested Ferneyhough as a subject for Total Immersion. No one needs to know much, but at least they'd get the idiom. But frankly, this time the BBC might as well not have bothered.
The evening concert was worthwhile, however. The UK premiere of Ferneyhough's 2006 Plötzlichkeit would be a Big Event in any situation. It's scored for massive forces - a Proms piece par excellence - and is as visually spectacular as it is to listen to. Big as it is, Martyn Brabbins understands how it works, so the BBCSO make it move with great energy.
Plötzlichkeit is made up of over 100 segments in 23 minutes. Thus the idea of "suddenness", new ideas popping u up unexpectedly, flying past before you can quite take them in. It's like a densely populated panorama, where everything's moving on different levels and directions. Fascinating because it can't be taken in all at once. The more you listen, the more you get. Ferneyhough described it to Julian Anderson in an impromptu talk, surrounded by the musicians. "No global strategy" in the structure, which evolves instead from the fragments themselves. It's this inventiveness that gives momentum to what might seem an unwieldy work in theory. There are elements left open and what Ferneyhough calls "inserts", passages not related to the other sections, which help anchor the work as it flows onwards. Always surprises to add sparkle, like descant trombones, or instruments played out of kilter. Three voices are embedded in the orchestra so they pop out unexpectedly. At first I thought they were synthesized, so that was a surprise for me. It must be heaven to study this piece in depth, observing the mathematical relationships and signifiers, but it works fine on a basic emotional level. It seizes your imagination and perks you up.
"No liberty without restraint" said Ferneyhough of his work. Often there's a sense of crawling out of traps, breaking bounds, struggling against overwhelming forces. The picture is one of a series called Carceri d'invenzione. by Giovanni Battista Piranesi (1720-78) showing unimaginably complex dungeons. Staircases lead to obstacles. Drawbridges are drawn up suddenly, blocking escape. Throughout, a sense of vertigo, where all that's gained could be lost in a sudden fall. Perhaps it's no accident that Ferneyhough was drawn to these engravings for his own series. Engraving is a painstakingly slow process which demands concentration on detail. Psychologically, it's forcible restraint. One mistake and the whole plate is wrecked.
Ferneyhough limits his palette this time to strings and winds but Carceri d'invenzione III (1986) still sounds like intense chamber music on a larger scale. A solo clarinet calls you into the piece, and soon you're caught up in swirling turns and counterturns. The music ends with limpid simplicity, but by now, you don't trust the apparent freedom. As I've said before, gamers (especially those who play Dungeons and Dragons) would talke to Ferneyhough instinctively. If only they knew! The market for Ferneyhough might be bigger than we realize.
Missa Brevis demonstrates Ferneyhough's interest in polyphony. The BBC Singers are among the best in the business, and are completely competent,. But the piece is a lot quirkier than this performance would suggest. A few years ago at Orford, I heard it as part of a programme with Ockeghem and others, sung by Exaudi, who specialize in this genre. How shockingly unique it sounded! Even when Missa Brevis was written in 1969, Ferneyhough was distinctively different.
Hearing La terre est un homme (1976-9) after hearing Plötzlichkeit (2006) showed how far Ferneyhough has come. There are similarities, such as the huge ensemble and the sense of great portent. But it's a good show stopper because it's relatively easy to digest. Tuttis and crescendi soar like waves, but details like solo piccolo help you identify with the human scale of the work. Simple instruments like an uncommonly small trumpet, probably a specialist type, clapped sticks and tambourines. Magical long ending that dissipates into silence.
In the short 1pm concert, we'd heard Quatuor Diotima play Ferneyhough's very early Sonatas for String Quartet. "I was young then " Ferneyhough told Anderson. "I couldn't understand why Webern wanted to write miniatures, so I wanted to fill them out". Big mistake, since Webern was right. A bit cruel to give this piece of near juvenilia such prominence when so many important works were left out. One wouldn't expect the Diotima to venture too far into Arditti territory by essaying the Sixth String Quartet (featured at the Wigmore Hall and at the Symposium) but surely there could have been other choices? The main reason for its inclusion might have been to highlight the sophistication of Plötzlichkeit but there's more to Ferneyhough than that.
Thank goodness Ferneyhough and Julian Anderson had a few moments together on the platform before the concert. Total Immersion Day had started with the comment, "The most amazing thing about Ferneyhough is that he was born in Coventry", which was met by a loud collective snort of derision from the audience. On the BBC Radio 3 broadcast this "amazing" concept was further developed, to explain Ferneyhough moving to Germany, which had also been bombed. But surely music comes into it, somehow? Then a long snip of Fürtwängler to illustrate that what is played isn't necessarily just the notes. Given that anyone who's heard of Fürtwängler can figure that out anyway, it's pretty pseud. Then the mock "interview" on the broadcast. Surely it would have been better to use Ferneyhough's own words from the 4pm interview instead of letting Tom Service repeat what he'd heard then? Surely they could have used a tape of Ferneyhough and Anderson speaking before the concert, since they were taping the concert itself ? Infinitely more enlightening. Most people listen to learn, not unlearn. The BBC really must address the dumbing down of Total Immersion days.
Please read aboutt the Ferneyhough Symposium HERE There is a review of the UK premiere of the Sixth String Quartet London premiuere HERE
Dark, fractured shards shroud the stage at the Guildhall School of Music and Drama for Francois Poulenc's Dialogues des Carmélites. The shards resemble broken glass, as if the audience is peering through a window that has been shattered. For the French Revolution has shattered society: everything's being smashed, the convent, the aristocracy and innocent lives. It's also a vivid metaphor, for Poulenc's edgy, angular music thrusts and cuts relentlessly. No easy lyricism here even if Poulenc's idiom is easier on the ear than many other composers' might be, given such material. This production, directed by Stephen Barlow and designed by David Farley, is impressive because it's so musically astute. Full review in Opera Today HERE. Dialogues des Carmélites is an unusual opera because it unfolds as a series of disconnected tableaux, like the Stations of the Cross. This structure is significant, for Poulenc is connecting the nun's journey to the guillotine to Christ's journey to the cross. Poulenc further emphasizes the non-linear progression by writing expressive interludes which are almost as much part of the narrative as the text. In "normal" productions this subtlety can be lost. At the Guildhall, the shards close in, isolating the stage, so the audience is forced to pay attention to what's happening in the orchestra. Simple inexpensive staging but extremely effective. I suspect they're just boards swathed in velour, but litt from above, the shards look like glass. Lit from behind, they resemble rocks. (lighting design : Declan Randall). The shards also hide the many scene changes, so momentum isn't wasted. A practical as well as an artistic solution to the musical demands of this remarkable opera.
This is what good stagecraft should be, created around music and meaning. This isn't a typical opera because it's very direct and to the point. No decoration in the music, so no fussy effects on the stage. In the Final Act, the mob descends on the Place de la Révolution. The guillotine is shown only in the distance, hidden by the mob, who are dressed in shades of red. As the mob moves, the red moves, like a stream of blood. No need to depict the executions - the image expresses so much. The nuns stand in a line confronting the audiernce. In real life they'd hardly be wearing immaculate vestments, but spiritually they're already among the angels, as one by one, each nun is picked out by spotlight. At last the shards are vanquished, like the barbarism they depict. Sister Blanche of the Agony of Christ is shown alone in a moment of glory, transfigured with light.
This production is so good it could be transferred to a much bigger, higher-budget house and still be astounding. Since the Guildhall also teaches stagecraft, it means that the students will be learning their business from good hands. Even singers and musicians benefit, because by taking part, they're learning how intelligent, musically-informed staging is made. A useful skill now that audio only recordings no longer dominate the industry and opera is once again appreciated as all-round drama.
It's a pleasure to watch how the GSMD students respond. For a change, they're acting very well, for Barlow's good at directing people. Very natural movement, often closely co-ordinated with musical detail. Nicely blocked crowd scenes, concentrated when needed (as in the mob), diffuse when the nuns feel isolated in their travail. The nuns are treated like individuals, which is what they are, despite the regimention of the Carmel. Principals are well cast too - it's good to hear familiar voices get good exposure.
The role of Blanche in Dialogues des Carmélites is interesting, because Poulenc isn't explicit but hints at worrying traits of neurosis and self-delusion. Something's very not right about a girl who screams at the butler's shadow and causes her brother such anguish. Nowadays such girls wouldn't be accepted into the novitiate. Whoever sings Blanche needs to fill in the backstory for herself, so it's convincing when Blanche makes her sacrifice. Anna Patalong sings 3/3 and 7/3, Natalya Romaniw on 5/3 and 9/3. They're both major names at GSMD.
Blanche is emotionally vulnerable while the old Mother Superior, Madame de Croissy (Cátia Moreso) seems strong but dies a traumatic death. It's a high point in the opera because it reverses the idea of a pious person being free from doubt. Moreso sings with a force that belies her supposed physical weakness. Poulenc's not into literalism but spiritual veracity. Just as Blanche's music is hyper, so is Mme de Croissy's, though of course in different ways. Both are more affected by the turmoil around them than they let on.
Mère Marie (Sylvie de Bedouelle and Amy J Payne), Mère Jeanne (Sioned Davies) and Madame Lidoine (Sky Ingram) are all strong, conventional characters. The book that inspired the play on which Poulenc based his opera was written by a German feminist, Gertrud von le Fort, who could see what was happening around her in the 1930's. The French Revolution didn't have a monopoly on mobs. The male principals too are relatively conventional parts, very solidly created. Gary Griffiths and Koji Terada alternate as the Marquis de la Force, Charlie Mellor and Paul Curievici as the Chevalier and Alberto Sousa sings the priest. Excellent
So pay attention to the role of Soeur Constance. She drives Blanche to distraction because she's so irrepressibly cheerful, but she is the one who intuits the meaning of Mme Croissy's death. Sophie Junker sings the part vivaciously, and Barlow directs her to leap and dance. Psychologically right, although Carmelites are a semi-silent order. Constance isn't a typical heroine, but she's so full of joie-de-vivre that the sacrifice the nuns will make is thrown into high perspective. Lovely ensemble singing and hymns.
Yet Dialogues des Carmélites, despite its religious subject, isn't as solemn as might seem. It's distinctively Poulenc, and Poulenc's sardonic. Blanche is devout but her music verges on deranged. The Prioress acts like she's older than Methuselah but she's only 59 (and Poulenc lets us know exactly how her life was divided). Her death scene's over the top, so it's almost funny how the nuns are shocked. Doubly ironic when you realize Poulenc's best friend was dying when he wrote this music. It's like whistling in the graveyard, overcoming fear by denying its power. Typical Poulenc irony. Listen to some of the key wind parts, too, especialy the sour-sweet solos, and the raucous churning in the strings. Soeur Constance's lively spirit could come straight out of Banalités (which are anything but banal) or Les mamelles de Tirésias. Poulenc's elegant, ironic wit cannot be silenced any more than the nuns' faith can be supressed. A more formal improved version of this will appear in Opera Today.
http://www.operatoday.com/content/2011/03/poulenc_dialogu.phpThe most exciting show in town and it's a Guildhall production! HERE IS FULL REVIEW. Which shows, never underestimate the power of student productions. Superlative Poulenc Les Dialogues des Carmélites at the Guildhall School of Music and Drama tonight. Ths one's a force to be reckoned with - way better than many high-budget big houses. Extremely tightly focused stage action (Stephen Barlow) perfectly in tune with the orchestra (which matters with Poulenc). Marvellous set (David Farley), which expresses both music and drama and also overcomes the practical challenges the constant scene changes create. Good performances all round too. If GSMD students are learning at this level, who knows what great things they'll go on to
in the future? This is a very unusual opera, but the production is extremely well thought through. Someone understands Poulenc's idiom and what the opera really means!
I'll write much more later because this is so good that it really deserves in-depth comment. Get to it if you can - it's fabulous ! Next performances: Saturday 5th, Monday 7th and Wednesday 9th. More thru this link.
"Let's not use the C-word" said someone at the IMR Ferrneyhough Symposium in the Senate House, London, part of a two part Ferneyhough Total Immersion. Meaning, "Let's not talk about New Complexity in case it scares the punters". But why? Brian Ferneyhough is complex, which is precisely why he's fascinating. No-one needs to know every little detail to get pleasure (and pain) from Ferneyhough's music. Indeed, effort is part of the process. Res severa est verum gaudium, "true pleasure is a serious business".
One of the papers at the conference was about time organization in Caceri d'Invenzione II. The 'irregular metronome' occurs along mutually-interacting layers of time organization... (and part) of a graduated tension field between large tempo relations and subtle metric nuances". But even someone like me can follow the gist of that. Like Ferneyhough's music, there are lots of different levels through which you can enter and progress. So what if it's complex? That's where the fun lies.
Fun and Ferneyhough? Yes! Gamers would love this music because it can function like a supremely devious puzzle, with so many possible angles that you can get something whatever level you operate on. In his keynote address Ferneyhough himself spoke about jigsaws. When you're fitting the pieces together are you fitting physical shapes or "making" a picture ? Why do things fall in place the way that they do? Why do the pieces lock together even though the shapes seem random? Is it the shapes we follow or the image? What if the picture is abstract or blank? For me the fascination of Ferneyhough's music is exactly this sense of multidimensional plasticity, like the staircases in this MC Escher etching, or the one where birds morph into fish in a stylized pattern. Obviously the more you can analyze, the more you get, but there's no reason why the process shouldn't be enjoyable because it's elusive. It's boring if you can get everything instantly.
Another good paper at the symposium was Matteo Cesari's Achievement of the Unachievable. Cesari's a flautist and worked with Ferneyhough to try to crack the code to his formidably arcane manuscripts. Millions of tiny markings, intricate instructions. Yet the secret is to interpret what goes into a performer's psyche and what makes it through to audible sound. Performance is more than mechanical note-processing, it's a creative act of engagement with a composer's inner world. Sisyphus was cursed by the gods to keep rolling stones uphill, which would roll back each night. Enormous effort, and a goal that could never be achieved. Yet there's a kind of warped logic in the situation. Maybe no-one will find nirvana but if you don't even start to try, there's no chance at all. One thing these papers didn't go nowhere near is Ferneyhough's interest in the darker, almost S&M aspects of challenge - Antonin Artaud's Theatre of Cruelty and the idea that sublimation can be achieved through extreme stress. Part of Ferneyhough's uncompromising asperity is this journey past the boundaries of comfort.
Then there's the metaphysical side to Ferneyhough's music. It's not simply that he's interested in early music polyphony and the cosmic mindset that comes with it. Julian Anderson reading Lois Fitch's paper linked Ferneyhough to Blake for both approach the universe with a sense of mystery. Blake's God is unsettling, his relationship to man not quite as benevolent as it might be in the Bible. Yet the concepts are deeply embedded in the music itself. Fabrice Fitch's paper Polyphony : Ferneyhough and prima prattica drew the connection between Ferneyhough's arcane notation and early medieval practice. Notations in early music aren't standardized, for music was passed on through oral tradition. Traditional forms within which there was improvisation and invention. Ferneyhough not only quotes from early polyphony but integrates the mentality.
Therre was a screening of Colin Still's latest documentary Climbing a Mountain- Ferneyhough's Sixth String Quartet (produced by Paul Archbold) made with the Arditti Quartet at Donaueschingen in 2010. Still's films are wonderfully informative, so I hope we get to see this one again. There was a short evening concert, too, with Ensemble Exposé (cond Roger Redgate) which featured O Lux, a UK premiere.
What is so frightening about complexity that it puts Ferneyhough's music somehow out of bounds? Frankly I don't care if he never makes it on Top of the Pops, because popularity is no arbiter of quality. There is a snobbishness in new music circles that would like to exclude mere mortals from the Chosen Few, but it's not necesarily best for the music, or indeed, for the masses. At the Saturday Barbican evening concert there were quite a few in the audience who had no idea who Ferneyhough was and came along because it was a Night Out. They seemed to be having a good time even though it might not quite have been what they expected. If you set yourself up for difficulty, difficulty is what you get. But there are many ways into Ferneyhough, one of which is simple instinct. Ferneyhough talks in convoluted sentences but inside there's an extraordinarily sharp mind that's surprisingly accessible. Because the venue for the post-symposium party was changed I misdirected Ferneyhough to the wrong building, so he went on a wild goose chase. When he came back, he scolded me with a twinkle in his eye, "They'll have finished all the drinks!"
Where do Big Names come from in the first place? If we don't nurture the unknown and upcoming, who will be there in the future? Like any healthy organism, music revives itself by growth and renewal. That's why it's good to support schemes like th PLG Young Artists.and others.
Since its inception in 1956, many Park Lane Group Young Artists have gone on to good things: Thomas Adès, Gwyneth Jones, Thomas Allen, Claire Booth, Mark van der Weil, Anthony Rolfe Johnson, Stephen Isserlis and many others. Performance isn't something that can be done in theory. Performers need to be perform live so they get the experience of interacting with audiences.
The Wigmore Hall is an important part of the scheme because it's hallowed ground. On this platform almost everyone significant in chamber music and song has appeared. Just look at the walls with their photos and posters of concerts past. A programme with Poulenc and Bernac appeared near the lift once, for example. One day when the WH gets its archive fully sorted there should be a major exhibition. Also, the Wigmore Hall is bigger than the Purcell Room at the South Bank. This year there are several PLG concerts running until June. Last Monday I attended the second concert in the series, with Tamsin Waley Cohen and the Piatti Quartet. There were many interesting people in the audience, including José Serebrier (who has mentored Tamsin Waley-Cohen), Anthony Payne the composer and the singer Jane Manning, herself a PLG Young Artist once, and from whom I and many others have learned so much.
Since I last heard Waley-Cohen play Tchaikovsky's Violin Concertoin 2007, she's matured a lot, though she's still only 25. This time she played Bartók's Sonata for Solo Violin which exposes a violinist's real skill and stamina. It was written for Yehudi Menuhin, no less and involves demanding technique. After a tentaive first movement, she collected herself and by the third and fourth movements acquitted herself with aplomb. She negotiated the tricky changes in the Melodia and the wild buzzing flights of the Presto with ease. A piece like this grows with a performer. One day Waley-Cohen will have the confidence to throw herself instinctively into the work. She was playing the same 1721 Stradivarius that Lorand Fenyves used when he played this very same piece at a PLG concert in 1964. Menuhin, Fenyves and so many others. This weight of grand tradition would intimidate many, but Waley-Cohen has courage. Later she played Richard Causton's Fantasia and Air (2009) commissioned for her, and Bach's Chaconne BVW 1004.
The Piatti String Quartet comprise Charlotte Scott, Michael Trainor, David Wigram and Jessie Ann Richardson. In the first half of the programme they played Beethoven's String Quartet in E flat major op 74. Very well co-ordinated, very well balanced. To their credit the Piatti were interesting and held attention. Again, expressiveness grows with maturity, but with experience these players will develop. They've got the basics right. They ended the concert with Smetana's String Quartet no 1 in E minor.